California's law against credit card surcharges (Civil Code 1748.1) is still on the books. A 2018 federal appeals ruling stopped the state from enforcing it against the businesses that sued, and the Attorney General applies that ruling to businesses in the same position. The same law expressly allows a discount for paying by cash, check or debit card, offered to every customer. That makes a cash discount the clearest legal way to pass on card fees in California.
Key takeaways
- California Civil Code 1748.1 still says merchants can't surcharge credit card payments.
- A 2018 ruling (Italian Colors v. Becerra) blocked enforcement against the businesses that sued; the Attorney General applies it to similar businesses.
- Discounts for cash, check or debit are expressly allowed, as long as every customer is offered the discount.
- Under SB 478, an avoidable card fee doesn't have to be in the advertised price. If you only take cards, it does.
- Card network rules still apply: credit only, no more than your cost, clear signs and a receipt line.
California at a glance: Gray area. Use a cash discount. California's surcharge ban (Civil Code 1748.1) is still on the books. A 2018 ruling stopped enforcement only for businesses like the ones that sued. The same law expressly allows discounts for paying by cash, check or debit, so a cash discount is the clear route.
What California law says
Civil Code section 1748.1, passed in 1985, says a retailer can't add a surcharge when a customer pays by credit card instead of cash, check or similar means. The same section says a retailer may offer a discount for paying by cash, check or debit card, as long as the discount is offered to all customers.
In Italian Colors Restaurant v. Becerra (9th Cir. 2018), a federal appeals court held the surcharge ban couldn't be enforced against the five businesses that brought the case, because of how it restricted the way they described their prices. The California Attorney General's surcharge page says the office will generally apply that decision to merchants in a similar situation. The law itself was not repealed.
Does SB 478, the junk fee law, change this?
California's honest pricing law (SB 478), in effect since July 1, 2024, requires mandatory fees to be built into the advertised price. The Attorney General's guidance says a credit card processing fee generally isn't mandatory if the customer can avoid it by paying another way, such as cash. If your business only accepts credit cards, the fee becomes mandatory and has to be in the advertised price.
The safest setup in California
Post your regular price as the card price, then give a discount to anyone who pays with cash, check or debit. That's the structure 1748.1 expressly allows. Show the discount clearly at the entrance, at checkout and on invoices, and show it as its own line on the receipt.
If you'd rather add a surcharge at checkout, talk to a California business lawyer first. The ruling protects businesses similar to the plaintiffs, but the statute hasn't changed, and the details of how you describe the fee matter.
Sign and receipt wording for California
Our free credit card surcharge sign generator writes the entrance sign, checkout sign, invoice wording and receipt line for California using cash discount wording, the clearer route here. You can copy it, print it or email it to yourself.
Card network rules that apply in California
- Cap: Visa allows surcharges up to 3%, Mastercard up to 4%, and never more than your actual cost of accepting the card.
- Credit only: no surcharges on debit or prepaid cards.
- Notice: tell your processor at least 30 days before you start.
- Disclosure: post it before the customer shops or checks out, and again at the point of sale.
- Receipt: show the surcharge or discount as its own line.
What a surcharge or cash discount saves
When customers who pay by credit card cover the processing cost, your net fees drop sharply. Our processing partner's clients have cut fees 55% to 98%; one event services company went from $3,713 a month to $91.42. See how dual pricing compares with surcharging, or run your own numbers in the processing fee calculator.
Other states
See every state's status in credit card surcharge laws by state, or read the full rules for New York, Illinois, Texas and Florida.
Sources
- California Attorney General: Credit card surcharges
- California Attorney General: Hidden fees (SB 478) FAQ
- California Civil Code section 1748.1
Frequently asked questions
Is it illegal to charge a credit card fee in California?
Do I have to include a card fee in my advertised prices in California?
Can I offer a cash discount in California?
Can I add a fee to debit card payments in California?
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Card network rules and state laws change; confirm the rules for your business before changing how you charge customers.